How essential are playpens?

I am considering playpens as a safe space in our living room to contain my little one when she becomes more mobile. She is currently 4 months old, and I have a feeling she may start crawling early.

When I was pregnant, I looked at playpens but ultimately felt they weren’t necessary, and a playard would serve the same purpose, albeit in a smaller space.

However, I’m now realizing how challenging it is to keep my dog away from licking her or grabbing her toys (obviously, a playpen won’t solve this problem 100%). My dog is a little Pom-terrier and super gentle with kids, even when her tail is pulled, so I wouldn’t expect her to bite. Still, you can never be too cautious since even well-behaved dogs can be unpredictable. I also like the idea of being able to go to the bathroom and know that my dog can’t reach her, she can’t get into trouble, and I don’t have to carry her up to her crib every time.

Again, maybe the pack n play will fulfill this need, but I wonder if anyone has any other insights for or against a playpen? Thanks!

Our two dogs are of a reasonable size, but they are unaware of their stature and frequently run into people or objects, which is why we enjoyed ours when Bub was a little smaller. Having the playpen allowed us to spend time without being concerned about the dogs.

hallo folks listen,If your home is already baby-proofed and has a secure play area, a playpen may not be necessary. However, if there are areas in your living space that are unsafe for your baby to explore, a playpen can offer a helpful solution.

It’s great that you’re considering options to keep your little one safe as she becomes more mobile. Here are some insights on playpens and playards that might help you decide:

  1. Playpens: Playpens are essentially sturdy, mini fences that create a safe space for your baby to play.

They are easy to set up and can be used both indoors and outdoors. Playpens are great for allowing your baby to practice sitting, rolling over, crawling, and standing. However, they are not designed for sleeping and should only be used for playtime.

  1. Playards: Playards, on the other hand, are more versatile. They have a sturdy frame, breathable mesh sides, and a cushioned mattress.

Playards can be used as a safe play space, a nap area, or even a travel crib. Some playards come with additional features like a removable bassinet, changing station, and storage compartments.

This makes them a more comprehensive solution for various needs.
3. Pack 'n Play: The Pack 'n Play is a popular brand of playard that offers the versatility of a playard with the convenience of portability.

It can be used for playtime, naps, and even as a travel crib. The Pack 'n Play often comes with additional features like a bassinet and changing station, making it a multifunctional piece of baby gear.

Given your situation with your dog, a playard or Pack 'n Play might be a better option. They provide a safe and enclosed space for your baby to play and nap, while also keeping your dog at a distance.

This way, you can have peace of mind knowing that your baby is safe and secure, even when you need to step away for a moment.

Ultimately, the choice between a playpen and a playard depends on your specific needs and preferences.

If you need a versatile solution that can serve multiple purposes, a playard or Pack 'n Play might be the way to go. If you only need a safe play space, a playpen could suffice.

During my pregnancy, I considered these, but ultimately decided they weren’t necessary. I felt a playard would serve the same purpose, albeit in a smaller space. However, now I’m realizing how challenging it is to keep my dog from licking her or grabbing her toys (obviously, a playpen won’t completely solve this problem).